Wednesday, September 25, 2013

AA Rationale Chart


Specifications
Design 1
Design 2
Design 3
Design 4
Stability
4- very stabile, little chance of listing
3- sufficiently stabile, provides a good base for maneuvering
5- extremely stabile frame, little to no chance of flipping or heavy listing
1- very unstable, high chance of listing or tipping
Manufacturability
3- average, easy to find parts but numerous pieces
3- average, easy to find parts but numerous pieces
4- easy to find parts and few pieces to put together
5- easy to manufacture and find parts, few pieces
Cost
3- PVC piping
4- plastic demo kits
3- PVC piping
3-PVC piping
Mood
3- average, somewhat scientific not very adventurous
2- below average, appears to playful
4- good, appears adventurous and scientific
4- good, appears adventurous and scientific
Maneuverability
4- maneuvers well
4- maneuvers well
2- maneuvers steadily but very slowly, lots of drag
1- difficult to turn and maneuver
Space
3- average amount of space, enough room for arm and equipment
2- not enough space for arm plus equipment
5- more than enough room for arm to maneuver and to fit equipment
5- more than enough room for arm to maneuver and to fit equipment
Total Score
20
18
23
19
Average Rating
3.333
3
3.8333
3.1666
Rank
2
4
1
3

No comments:

Post a Comment